The review that didn't last

On Nov. 6, azcentral reported that the Arizona Department of Public Safety was reviewing Gilbert police files connected to the Republic reporter who broke the Goons story. The paper's headline that day also described DPS backtracking on that review.

A state agency that starts a review and then walks it back owes the public an explanation. The coverage we could access does not give one in detail.

What DPS says now

On Nov. 15, azcentral reported that a DPS spokesperson said the agency is not investigating Gilbert police over an alleged leak of a false rumor about the Republic reporter. The headline put it plainly: DPS won't look into Gilbert police over the leak.

The reporting we could access does not say what the rumor claimed or who passed it along. Those are the first questions anyone covering this should answer.

The 2024 rumor, in detail

The Republic reporter in question is Robert Anglen. In December 2024, azcentral reported that Gilbert Councilmember Chuck Bongiovanni had shared a false rumor in an attempt to discredit Anglen's Goons reporting. Anglen said the rumor falsely claimed he had a "history" with the police chief, including a domestic violence arrest, and described it as an effort to discredit the paper's inquiry into the department.

Anglen also said that when the paper asked Chief Michael Soelberg about the claim, Soelberg avoided saying whether he had shared the information with Bongiovanni or anyone else. He told reporters they would have to wait for police records on the matter.

The Republic also reported on texts from Bongiovanni. In them, he hinted at a "little personal issue" to explain why the reporter was pursuing the story. He did not describe that issue in the texts and declined to elaborate to Republic reporters. A town spokesperson answered on his behalf.

Nothing we found connects the 2024 rumor to the one at issue in November. The 2024 episode is documented, though, and it shows the same target and a similar claim about the reporter's personal life.

The chief on rumors

Soelberg has spoken publicly about the harm rumors can cause. He said a 17-year-old boy playing in front of his house was threatened after a rumor spread that the child was a murderer, and that the boy's address was leaked. The boy, the chief said, was not a suspect in any case. The coverage we reviewed does not date those remarks.

The department's top officer has said rumors can put children in danger. The question now is whether that principle applies when the rumor targets the reporters covering his department, and whether the chief answered questions about the 2024 claim the way he would want a rumor-spreader answered.

A department with a long paper trail

The Goons story began in December 2023, when the Republic tied the death of 16-year-old Preston Lord to a group of teenagers whose attacks had gone unchecked for more than a year. Gilbert police said soon after that they had not seen reports linking the group to any crimes. The department later reopened old cases, and the Republic reported that Soelberg had misled the public about how the department handled the Goons and other teen violence cases.

The department eventually declared the group a criminal street gang. ABC15 reported that no additional charges followed.

The records side is more complicated. In a July 1, 2026 letter, the Attorney General's Office told Soelberg that file deletions tied to a complaint from Charisa Marie Arnold resulted from an administrative error, and it found the complaint unsubstantiated. KJZZ reported that Gilbert had kept recordings well past the required retention period, and the department asked the AG for an independent review in February.

Both things can be true. The deletions were administrative, and the retention problem was real.

In October, a petition calling for Soelberg's removal, backed by Lord's grandfather, passed 1,600 signatures and demanded an independent review of how the department handled teen violence cases. ABC15 reports Soelberg now holds an interim town leadership role. Sources disagree on the exact title, so we are not using one.

What we are looking for

We want four things from the Gilbert Police Department and DPS:

  1. Communications about the Republic reporter, including any discussion of the rumor.

  2. The DPS review file, and the documents that explain why the review was dropped.

  3. Any record showing who first circulated the claim.

  4. Whether anyone filed a complaint, and where it went.

A rumor about a reporter is a serious allegation, and it deserves a serious answer. If it was false, the public should know who spread it. If someone in government passed it along, the public should know that too.

How we reported this: This story draws on published reporting by azcentral, the Arizona Republic, KJZZ, and ABC15, including Robert Anglen's December 2024 account of the Bongiovanni rumor, along with the Arizona Attorney General's July 1, 2026 letter to the Gilbert Police Department. We could not access the full text of the November 6 and November 15 azcentral stories, so the content and origin of the November rumor are not established here. Requests for comment and records requests to the Gilbert Police Department and DPS are the next steps, and this story will be updated with any responses.

Keep Reading